CRITERIA | POPULAR MAGAZINES | PROFESSIONAL/TRADE MAGAZINES | SCHOLARLY JOURNALS |
---|---|---|---|
Authors | Journalists, staff writers, popular authors, or it may not be listed | Staff writers and experts in the field | Researchers and experts |
Audience | The general public | Members of an industry, trade or profession | Researchers and experts |
Documentation | Sources are usually not cited | Sources may be cited | Sources are always cited |
Content | General interest, news or entertaining stories | Current trends, standards and new technology in a profession | Original research findings, scholarly reports, methodology and theory |
Language | Broad, simple language that anyone can understand | Jargon that assumes expertise in the field | Jargon that assumes expertise in the field |
Publisher | Commercial organizations | Associations | Associations or Universities |
Appearance | Glossy paper, advertisements, heavily illustrated in color | Glossy paper, Advertisements (most are trade-related) moderately illustrated in color | Plain paper, few or no advertisements (only academic-related), charts and graphs and some illustrations in black and white |
Review Policy | Reviewed by editors | Reviewed by editors | Reviewed by peers and experts in the field. The editorial board is made up of distinguished scholars. |
Examples | Newsweek, Economist, Psychology Today, Cooking Light |
Advertising Age, Publisher's Weekly, Chemical and Engineering News |
Journal of the American Medical Association, Journal of Southern History, Journal of Modern Literature, Journal of Marketing Research |
Copyright © Baylor® University. All rights reserved.
Report It | Title IX | Mental Health Resources | Anonymous Reporting | Legal Disclosures