Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Critical/Exegetical Commentaries

A guide for locating and using critical commentary sets available in Baylor University Libraries.

Distinguishing exegetical from general commentaries.

A Critical Bible commentary is a highly specialized work that focuses in detail on the text and its explication. Using the criteria from Stuart’s “Four Yardsticks”, we can make the following general observations. A critical commentary is almost always:

·         Size: One-to-one (or Several-to-one)

·         Detail: Detailed to In-depth

·         Level: Technical

While research methodology varies, depending upon the interests and specialization of the commentator, critical commentaries generally address the following kinds of issues:

·         Integrity of the text

o   What is the original form of the text? Attempts to zero in on most authentic (ergo reliable) version of the text in original languages

·         Textual and philological issues

o   Issues in translation of words or concepts, subtle shades of meaning, determining the most likely authorial/redactional intent for disputed text

·         Redactional issues (varies by methodology – most common in Historical/Critical works)

o   Theological slant and intent of final editor of biblical book

·         Literary and history of tradition issues (varies by methodology– most common in Historical/Critical works)

o   Discussion of prehistory of books component parts

·         Extensive discussion of background issues

o   World behind the text: historical, socio-political, cultural factors of authors/redactors

o   World of the text: historical, socio-political, cultural factors of recipients/characters

·         History of exegesis (varies by methodology)

·         Detailed treatment of text

o   Verse by verse or passage by passage treatment

·         Detailed analysis of disputed/controversial texts, with in-depth review of alternative scholarly interpretations

o   Preferred interpretation supported by cogent argument

·         Extensive scholarly bibliographies

University Libraries

One Bear Place #97148
Waco, TX 76798-7148

(254) 710-6702